Makes perfect sense to me. I definitely agree that labeling fics from a reviewer's standpoint of helping readers find fics they like is a different game than labeling fics to analyze trends in fanfic. So we wouldn't have to label them in the same way (even though I think we're in agreement on how to label this fic!)

Oh, and I also agree that most of what I love about sex in fics at all is what it means for the characters. PWP by itself is not nearly so interesting as what dicta called this: "Porn with feelings". So this being Harry's first time bottoming is important and part of the dynamic and is part of what gives this fic feels. And that is what I want :)